Game review with an icon of an older review projection tv wiith a side-scrolling game playing. The background is blue.
Gaming,  Off the Shelf

Is This Seat Taken? game review

If you’ve come to my Is This Seat Taken? game review wondering whether arranging a collection of fussy little characters into their preferred seats makes for a satisfying logic puzzle, the answer is yes. Although I would like to speak to the manager about their behaviour.

I’d been seeing Is This Seat Taken? everywhere. It had excellent reviews, people I follow were talking about it, and it seemed like the sort of game I would enjoy.

And for the most part, I do. I love logic puzzles. Give me a collection of rules, a problem to solve and enough information to work out the answer, and I’m generally pretty happy. And that’s essentially what Is This Seat Taken? offers.

In this game you have a group of little shapes, each with their own preferences about where they want to sit and who they’re prepared to sit next to. Your job is to arrange everyone so that all their requirements are met.

Sounds simple, right? Well, yes. And no.

Because while the puzzles become increasingly complex as you progress, I wouldn’t necessarily describe them as difficult. There’s a difference between having lots of information to consider and having a genuinely challenging problem to solve.

And Is This Seat Taken? sits somewhere in the middle.

I spent around six hours playing (noting this likely included me pausing to get a drink, put on laundry, etc.), completed every puzzle and unlocked all the achievements. I enjoyed myself enormously.

But I also spent a surprising amount of time wondering why some of these little shapes couldn’t just behave like reasonable adults.

 


 

If you’re interested in other cosy games I have reviewed, please click here for the Gaming reviews section on my blog.

5 pixelated red gaming hearts on each side of a pixelated gaming style wizard

Is This Seat Taken? game review

Is This Seat Taken? game logo

Title: Is This Seat Taken?
Developer: Poti Poti Studio
Publisher: Wholesome Games Presents
Release date: 8 August 2025
Players: 1 (single player only)
Platforms: Windows, Linux, Switch, PS5, iOS, Android
Genre: Casual, Logic, Puzzle, Indie, Cosy
Click to buy on Steam (this is not an affiliate link)

Is This Seat Taken?

Is This Seat Taken? is a logic puzzle game where you play matchmaker for groups of hilariously particular people. Each character has pet peeves that make seating them a delightful challenge. Find the perfect spot for each person to unlock new levels in this cozy, silly, and relatable experience.

– Steam

5 pixelated red gaming hearts on each side of a pixelated gaming style wizard

Everyone has an opinion about where they sit

The premise of Is This Seat Taken? is very straightforward.

You’re presented with a group of characters, each represented by a little shape, and a seating arrangement. Every character has a list of preferences or requirements (or demands), and you need to find a configuration that makes everyone happy.

Some characters don’t want to sit next to someone who smells. Others have particular preferences about their neighbours or surroundings.

As you progress, the game introduces increasingly specific situations. You might have someone standing up during a baseball game and blocking another character’s view, or someone who wants to steal food from the person sitting nearby.

Apparently, finding somewhere to sit is an extraordinarily complicated social undertaking. And what if the person with food doesn’t want to share?

Now, I understand why these requirements exist. Without them, there wouldn’t be a puzzle.

But I also found some of the characterisation a little uncomfortable.

There are characters whose defining characteristic is that other people don’t want to sit near them. Sometimes that’s because they smell, and while I understand not wanting to spend an entire journey beside someone with questionable personal hygiene, I also think there are occasions when we simply accept a mildly unpleasant situation because we’re adults.

Perhaps this is my conflict avoidance talking. Because the idea of getting up and moving seats on public transport because I didn’t like the person beside me? Absolutely not. That falls into the conflict bucket, and it doesn’t go here.

Personally, I would sit there, quietly uncomfortable, and endure the entire journey rather than risk making someone feel bad. Or worse, being confronted for moving seats.

I’ve actually been confronted on public transport for moving seats, and also for politely asking someone to stop talking on their phone in a designated ‘quiet carriage’. Which is precisely why I avoid these situations. (And before anyone asks, I would NEVER talk on my phone in a quiet carriage.)

The little shapes are perfectly happy to announce their requirements and expect everyone else to accommodate them. Some of them are, quite frankly, rude.

And although I can appreciate the humour the game is going for, it didn’t always land for me. Fortunately, the actual puzzle mechanics were considerably more appealing.

Complex doesn’t necessarily mean difficult

This is where Is This Seat Taken? really shines.

As you move through the game, the puzzles become increasingly complicated. New requirements are introduced, the seating arrangements change, and you need to consider more conditions simultaneously.

It’s no longer simply a matter of making sure two characters aren’t sitting beside each other.

You might need to account for someone wanting to sit next to their backpack, a character wanting to dance, or several competing preferences that affect where everyone else can go.

And I really enjoyed working through those combinations.

There’s something satisfying about looking at a collection of seemingly incompatible requirements and finding an arrangement that works.

I approached the puzzles logically, identifying the most restrictive conditions first and then working out where everyone else could fit around them. At least, that was logical to me.

I should probably acknowledge that my brain doesn’t always approach problems in quite the same way as everyone else’s, so your mileage may vary.

But I rarely found myself genuinely stuck. And I think that’s because the game is quite generous with its seating arrangements, even in the later stages.

There were generally more seats available than characters who needed them. You weren’t necessarily trying to find the one precise arrangement that would satisfy every requirement. You were finding an arrangement that worked, often with a little spare room to manoeuvre.

That makes the puzzles more accessible, which I think is a perfectly reasonable design choice. It also means that the increasing complexity doesn’t always translate into increasing difficulty. You might have more rules to juggle, but you’re not necessarily being asked to solve a more restrictive problem. I often felt there were multiple possible solutions, rather than the one exact answer you needed to find.

And while I enjoyed the game as it was, I would have loved some optional bonus puzzles that removed that flexibility. Give me exactly the number of seats I need. Make every placement matter. Force me to work out the one arrangement that satisfies all the conditions.

Not necessarily throughout the main game, because I appreciate that not everyone wants their cosy puzzle experience to become an examination in advanced logic. But as an optional challenge for people who enjoy that sort of thing? Yes, please.

I finished the game wanting more puzzles that really tested how well I’d learned its mechanics. Which, I suppose, is a pretty good indication that I enjoyed them.

The puzzles are the main attraction

One of the things I found less compelling about Is This Seat Taken? was its presentation.

I’m not a huge fan of the visual style. The little shapes have personality, certainly, but the overall aesthetic didn’t particularly appeal to me.

And while I know that music and atmosphere can contribute enormously to the cosy-game experience, I don’t remember the soundtrack making much of an impression. In fact, I suspect I turned the music off.

What kept me playing wasn’t the presentation. It was the puzzles. And that’s also why I occasionally found myself wishing the game would spend less time on its story.

There’s a narrative element connecting the puzzles, but I didn’t find it particularly engaging. It felt more like something happening between the puzzles than a story I was invested in following.

Which isn’t inherently a problem. Not every puzzle game needs an elaborate narrative, and I don’t think Is This Seat Taken? would necessarily be better if it tried to tell a more complicated story.

But if the narrative isn’t particularly compelling, I’d rather spend that time solving another puzzle. This is where I’d distinguish it from something like The Last Campfire.

The Last Campfire uses puzzles as part of a larger, emotionally engaging experience. You’re solving problems, but you’re also invested in the world, its characters and the journey you’re taking.

For me, Is This Seat Taken? works in almost the opposite direction. The puzzles are the reason to play. Everything else is secondary.

And that’s absolutely fine, provided you know what you’re getting.

By the time I’d finished, I still didn’t feel that the puzzle mechanics had worn out their welcome. If anything, I wanted the game to push them a little further.

I’d happily recommend it to people who enjoy logic puzzles, particularly those who like working through a set of rules and finding solutions through deduction.

I also think it could be a great option for teenagers or anyone wanting to practise logical reasoning without jumping straight into something intimidatingly difficult.

But if you’re looking for a story-driven cosy game, or something with the emotional depth of The Last Campfire, I wouldn’t approach this with those expectations.

Is This Seat Taken? is a clever, accessible puzzle game that gradually introduces more complicated problems without becoming particularly punishing. It doesn’t need to be anything more than that.

Although I still think some of its characters could benefit from a lesson in basic public transport etiquette. Because sometimes, my little geometric friends, you just have to sit next to someone you don’t particularly like.

It’s called living in a society.

5 pixelated red gaming hearts on each side of a pixelated gaming style wizard

Have you played Is this seat taken?

Two adorable cartoon cats play video games with colourful controllers, snuggled under a teal blanket with headphones, popcorn and a Stitch plushie. Text reads: “Until next time, happy gaming! Meeghan xo.”

Hi!! I'm Meeghan 😊 I like books (surprise). I also like games (board, video and D&D), baking (mostly cakes) and travel. I live in Canberra, Australia with Husband and 3 black rescue kitties.

Leave a Reply