Top 5 Tuesday post header with an image of 5 books stacked on a purple background
Top 5 Tuesday

Top 5 book boyfriends I could fix

Hello friends, and welcome to Top 5 Tuesday! This week’s topic is a freebie, and I decided to write about my top 5 book boyfriends I could fix. I swear I could!!

There are often only two types of fictional men.

The ones who are emotionally stable, communicate well, and would probably make excellent long-term partners… and the ones who are a walking red flag with trauma, questionable decision-making, and just enough vulnerability to make you think, I could fix him.

This post is not about the first group. It’s about the second.

Because sometimes the appeal isn’t that they’re perfect… it’s that they’re almost there. That with just a little bit of emotional growth, a few honest conversations, and maybe some light therapy, they could be everything.

Will it work? Unclear.
Will I try anyway? Absolutely.

If you’re looking for book boyfriends who could be fixed (in theory), these are my top five… and yes, I stand by all of them.

T5T post divider — two swirls on either side of a pile pf 5 books

InLinkz reminder

A reminder to everyone before we begin: We’re using InLinkz! What this means is that you will be in charge of linking your own posts here! Rather than me scouring the web (or my spreadsheet) for them. I will likely be posting ahead of everyone because of *timezones*, so it should be relatively easy for everyone to drop links for your posts. Unless I screwed something up. (It happens more often than you think…)


Upcoming topics

Top 5 Tuesday topics for 2026 are here. If you have an idea for a topic, I am always open to hearing it! The date format is DD/MM/YY, and topics are listed by month. You can even click on tabs for previous years and check out past topics too.

Top 5 Tuesday was created by Shanah @ Bionic Book Worm, and is now being hosted here at Meeghan reads.

T5T post divider — two swirls on either side of a pile pf 5 books

top 5 book boyfriends I could fix

Cardan Greenbriar — The Folk of the Air series

Book cover of The Cruel Prince by Holly Black

Cardan is the blueprint.

Cruel, arrogant, deeply defensive… and yet very clearly shaped by the environment he grew up in. He lashes out because it’s what he’s been taught, not necessarily who he wants to be, which is what makes him feel fixable rather than fundamentally broken.

What makes Cardan such a strong “I could fix him” candidate is that the softness is already there, it’s just buried under layers of pride and survival instinct. You see glimpses of it early on, in moments where he almost chooses kindness but doesn’t quite know how to follow through.

He doesn’t need to be rebuilt from scratch… just given the space, and maybe the right person, to become who he already has the potential to be. Which, honestly, feels like half the work done.

Cassian — A Court of Thorns and Roses series

Book cover of A Court of Thorns and Roses by Sarah J Maas

Cassian is interesting because he doesn’t look like someone who needs fixing.

He’s loyal, brave, emotionally open in a lot of ways, and far more grounded than most of the men around him. But if you look a little closer, there’s a pattern of self-sacrifice and a tendency to tie his worth to what he can give or do for others.

Which means the “fix” here is subtle.

It’s about learning to prioritise himself, to recognise that he doesn’t have to earn his place by constantly putting others first, and to unpack some of that deeply ingrained self-worth stuff. He’s already a good person… he just doesn’t always treat himself like one.

Low chaos. High emotional payoff.

Kaz Brekker — Grishaverse series

Book cover of Six of Crows by Leigh Bardugo

This one is less “fix” and more… proceed with caution.

Kaz is brilliant, strategic, and emotionally locked down to a level that would concern most therapists. His trauma isn’t just backstory it actively informs every decision he makes and every relationship he allows himself to have.

Which means you’re not fixing him quickly. Or easily.

But the reason he’s here is because the capacity for connection is there, even if it’s buried incredibly deep. The moments where he almost lets someone in are what make him feel like a “fixable” character rather than a completely closed-off one.

It would take time. And patience. And probably a very strong sense of emotional self-preservation.

But theoretically… not impossible.

Will Herondale — Shadowhunters

Book cover of Clockwork Angel by Cassandra Clare

Will Herondale is the definition of self-sabotage disguised as personality.

He pushes people away before they can get close, leans heavily into sarcasm and arrogance, and makes decisions based on fear rather than trust. On the surface, it reads as confidence. Underneath, it’s very clearly something else.

Which is exactly why he fits this list so well.

The “fix” here isn’t about changing who he is, it’s about removing the barriers he’s built around himself. Once those walls come down (even slightly), you start to see the loyalty, humour, and depth that were there the whole time.

High emotional damage potential. But also… very fixable, given the right circumstances.

Ronan Lynch — The Raven Cycle

Book cover of The Dream Thieves by Maggie Stiefvater

Ronan is chaos in human form.

He’s angry, impulsive, deeply loyal, and not always great at expressing anything that isn’t frustration or defiance. But underneath that is someone who feels everything very intensely and doesn’t always know what to do with it.

Which is where the “fixable” energy comes in.

Ronan doesn’t lack emotion… he lacks the tools to process and communicate it in a way that doesn’t default to anger. The potential for growth is absolutely there, especially when he’s given space to be understood rather than judged.

This is not an easy fix. (And probably hindered by the fact that I am not his type.) But it is, arguably, one of the most rewarding ones.

T5T post divider — two swirls on either side of a pile pf 5 books

Can we actually fix them?

No. But that’s not really the point.

What makes these characters so compelling is that they sit in that space between broken and whole. They have flaws, they make questionable choices, but they also have the capacity to grow.

And as readers, we get to explore that growth safely… without actually having to deal with the consequences.

Which, honestly, feels like the ideal situation.

T5T post divider — two swirls on either side of a pile pf 5 books

PARTICIPANTS

You are invited to the Inlinkz link party!

Click here to enter

Who are your top 5 ‘fixable’ book boyfriends?

Until next time, happy reading! Meeghan xo - image has 2 cats sitting over an open book.

Hi!! I'm Meeghan 😊 I like books (surprise). I also like games (board, video and D&D), baking (mostly cakes) and travel. I live in Canberra, Australia with Husband and 3 black rescue kitties.

Let's chat!